Stockholm syndrome: UK consumers love their supermarkets even as food inflation runs at nearly 2.5 times that in Europe

Why is UK inflation running at a much higher rate than European inflation?  The UK’s CPI is 4.5% compared with 2.7% in Europe.  One answer might be food inflation, a major portion of the overall CPI baskets (11% in the UK, 15% in the Eurozone – add in alcohol and both are a little higher).

Eurozone and UK inflation baskets

 

The chart below shows that the UK rate of food inflation is systematically higher than that in Europe.  At the moment the year on year increase is 4.7% compared with 2%, and at times the difference has been much higher.  There are times when you might explain this through £ weakness feeding into imported food prices, but the chart includes periods of both currency strength and weakness.  What else might explain structurally higher food inflation in the UK?
UK and Euro Area food price inflation

Well the chart below from Mark Capleton of SocGen might be at least part of the answer.  It shows earnings per share (EPS) growth for UK and European food retailers.  When food price inflation started to moderate post the last shock in 2008, European food retailers cut prices.  In the UK the supermarkets realised that they had pricing power and kept raising them; this resulted in the strong relative profitability that they enjoyed.  There might be other factors involved – the UK supermarkets have massively diversified into non-food goods (everything from clothing to DVDs to insurance), but it does look like UK consumers are being hit by the lack of competition in the food retail sector.
UK and Euro Area food retailer EPS, rebased

The BBC Watchdog survey from 2009 shows that only 2% of respondents were “very dissatisfied” with their supermarket (about half were actively “very satisfied”).  Yet they claim that price is the most important thing in their choice of shop.  Stockholm Syndrome is a “paradoxical psychological phenomenon wherein hostages express empathy and have positive feelings towards their captors”.

The value of investments will fluctuate, which will cause prices to fall as well as rise and you may not get back the original amount you invested. Past performance is not a guide to future performance.

Discuss Article

  1. David Battersby says:

    This all makes perfect sense but does not tell us what inflation would be without supermarkets. A lot higher I suspect.

    Posted on: 02/06/11 | 8:55 am
  2. Justin Pugsley says:

    Yeah, somehow that argument makes sense. I bet you d find something similar with utilities. In essence the lack of real competition is making inflation worse in the UK than it should be.

    Posted on: 02/06/11 | 12:20 pm

Leave a comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.